Introduction
The sports card market continues to sizzle in 2026, showing no signs of slowing down. From football to basketball, baseball, and hockey, collectors and investors are seeing significant movement in card values. This week, several athletes have made headlines for their on-field performances and off-field news, driving up demand for their rookie and iconic cards.
Whether you're a seasoned sports card investor or a casual collector, understanding which cards are gaining momentum is essential for making informed decisions. Today, we break down the top five sports cards by Sports Card Investor, making waves in the market, highlight their recent trends, and give expert insight into potential future performance.
Sports Card Market Pulse
The overall sports card market remains robust, with early 2026 continuing the momentum from a strong 2025. According to the SEI 500 Index, which tracks the top 500 sports cards, there has been nearly a 2% increase over the past week and a 4% gain since January 1st.
Collectors are actively tracking cards across all major sports, and the demand is particularly high for players who are performing well this season or have recently made impactful team moves. Platforms like Market Movers have become essential tools for monitoring price fluctuations and spotting opportunities to buy or sell before trends shift.
Now, let’s dive into this week’s top five hottest sports cards.
Top 5 Hottest Sports Cards
5. Tage Thompson
Rising to prominence in the NHL, Tage Thompson has been instrumental for the Buffalo Sabres over the past month. His offensive production, including seven goals and nine assists in the last 10 games, has boosted interest in his cards.
-
2017 Upper Deck Young Guns Base (PSA 10): from $67 to $169
-
2017 Upper Deck Young Guns Canvas (PSA 10): from $37 to $98
-
2017 Upper Deck Young Guns Canvas (Raw): Up 75% in 30 days
Thompson’s combination of size, skill, and consistency on the ice has collectors speculating that he could be a long-term asset for the Sabres and a strong card-market performer.
4. Kevin McGonigle
Kevin McGonigle, a middle infield prospect for the Detroit Tigers, had an impressive 2025 season with a .305 batting average, 408 on-base percentage, and 19 home runs. Card collectors are betting on his upcoming MLB call-up, driving significant increases in his card values.
-
2025 Bowman Chrome Prospects Base (PSA 10): from $70 to $100
-
2025 Bowman Chrome Prospects Reptilian Refractor (PSA 10): from $104 to $117
-
2025 Bowman Chrome Prospect Auto (Raw): from $200 to $350
-
2025 Bowman Chrome Prospect Auto Refractor /499 (Raw): from $450 to $576
McGonigle’s consistent minor league performance and potential major league breakout make his cards a hot commodity in the baseball segment.
3. Jarrett Stidham
With Bicks sidelined for the rest of the season, Jarrett Stidham is stepping in as the starting quarterback for the Broncos during a crucial playoff stretch. The news alone has sent his card prices skyrocketing overnight.
-
2019 Donruss Rated Rookie Auto Bronze (Raw): from $15 to $55
-
2019 Prizm Base (PSA 10): from $6 to $50
-
2019 Prizm Silver (Raw): from $8 to $30
-
2019 Select Concourse PSA 10: from $5 to $21
Sudden role changes and playoff opportunities often create short-term surges in card values, and Stidham is a perfect example.
2. Kyle Tucker
After signing with the Dodgers, Kyle Tucker has become a key figure in the MLB card market. Known for his power, on-base skills, and consistency, Tucker’s move to LA is fueling speculation about a big season ahead.
-
2015 Bowman Draft Chrome Auto (BGS 9.5): from $110 to $400
-
2019 Topps Base Rookie (PSA 10): from $24 to $33
-
2019 Topps Chrome Refractor (PSA 10): from $27 to $82
-
2019 Topps Chrome Rookie Auto Refractor /499 (PSA 10): from $285 to $335
-
2025 Topps Update Homefield Advantage (Raw): Slight fluctuation; watch for Dodgers version
Tucker’s high-profile move and proven track record make his rookie and early cards particularly attractive for collectors looking for growth potential.
1. Sam Darnold
Sam Darnold secures the number one spot this week after leading the Seahawks to a victory over the 49ers and positioning the team for the NFC Championship. Darnold threw for 287 yards and three touchdowns, reinforcing his momentum and boosting his card market activity.
-
2018 Donruss Base (PSA 10): up 82% from $30 to $82
-
2018 Optic Base (PSA 10): from $60 to $108
-
2018 Optic Downtown (PSA 10): from $630 to $1,000+
-
2018 Prizm Base (PSA 10): from $42 to $90–$100
-
2018 Prizm Silver (Raw): up to $95
-
2018 Select Concourse Silver (Raw): from $8 to $16
At all price points, Darnold’s cards are rising, reflecting both his personal performance and Seattle’s strong team momentum.
FAQs
1. What is causing the recent surge in sports card prices?
Recent on-field performances, playoff pushes, rookie breakthroughs, and high-profile trades or signings are driving collector demand and increasing card values.
2. How can I track sports card market trends?
Platforms like Market Movers allow collectors to monitor prices, track investments, and find the best deals in real time.
3. Are rookie cards more valuable than other cards?
Rookie cards often see higher demand because they mark the player’s entry into the professional league and can appreciate significantly with performance or hype.
4. Should I invest in current players or legends?
Both have potential. Current players can offer short-term gains based on news and performance, while legends like Dominique Wilkins maintain long-term value due to historical significance.
5. How do PSA grades impact card prices?
Higher PSA grades (e.g., 9 or 10) significantly increase value, as collectors pay premiums for near-perfect condition cards.
6. Can card prices drop quickly?
Yes. Player performance, injuries, or market corrections can lead to rapid declines, so diversification and research are essential.
Conclusion
The sports card market continues to reward collectors who stay informed and proactive. This week, rising stars like Tage Thompson and Kevin McGonigle, breakout opportunities for Jarrett Stidham, high-profile MLB moves by Kyle Tucker, and the consistent performance of Sam Darnold are driving excitement and price momentum.
By monitoring platforms like Market Movers, staying updated on player performance, and strategically investing, collectors can capitalize on trends while minimizing risks. 2026 is shaping up to be another thrilling year for the sports card hobby.
------------------------------------------------------
Want more? Here are a few great articles to check out: