Introduction
The sports card market has always been a fascinating intersection of nostalgia, investment, and passion. But over the last year, it’s reached an entirely new level, especially when it comes to the legends of the game. From all-time greats like Michael Jordan and Lionel Messi to modern superstars like Aaron Judge, collectors have witnessed jaw-dropping increases in card values. Some have doubled, others tripled, and a few have even seen returns of over 700%.
This special GOAT edition of the Top 5 Sports Cards by Sports Card Investor and Market Movers takes a deep dive into the hottest cards that have surged in value, highlighting why these collectibles are more than just cardboard; they’re powerful assets in today’s booming market.
The Sports Card Market is Red-Hot
Before diving into the individual cards, let’s set the stage. The SCI 500 Index, which tracks 500 of the most prominent sports cards across all sports, is up over 21% year-to-date. That’s nearly double the S&P 500 and far outpaces the performance of cryptocurrencies.
Collectors and investors alike are taking notice. High-grade versions of iconic cards have become blue-chip assets, with some prices reaching record highs.
Top 5 GOAT Sports Cards on Fire This Week
#5. Bo Jackson
Bo Jackson remains one of the most electrifying athletes in history. His 1990 Score #697, featuring him in football pads holding a baseball bat, is one of the most recognizable cards of the era.
-
PSA 10 Value Increase a year ago: $222 → $430 (+94%)
-
PSA 9 Values Increase a year ago: It’s up to 1.7%.
-
Reason: Scarcity in gem mint condition and enduring nostalgia.
#4. Aaron Judge
The Yankees’ slugger, Aaron Judge, continues to be a fan favorite and a powerhouse investment. His first 2013 Bowman Draft Chrome autograph has soared in value.
-
PSA 10 Value Increase a year ago: $3,300 → $7,500 (+127%)
-
BGS 9.5 Value Increase a year ago: $1,500 → $3,500 (+133%)
-
Reason: Judge’s 62-home-run MVP season and face-of-the-franchise status.
#3. Lionel Messi
Messi’s card market is exploding, fueled by his 2022 World Cup victory and his legendary career at Barcelona and beyond. The 2004 Panini Mega Cracks considered his rookie cards, and a PSA 10 of this card just sold for around a million dollars.
-
PSA 8 Value Increase a year ago: $7,800 → $35,000 (+349%)
-
BGS 9.5 Value Increase a year ago: $40,000 → $66,000
-
Reason: Global soccer card boom and Messi’s GOAT status cemented.
#2. Barry Bonds
Barry Bonds is the longtime left fielder for the Pittsburgh Pirates, is regarded as one of the greatest hitters of all time, even with the steroid controversy. His 1987 Topps Tiffany edition has become the crown jewel of the junk wax era. It has a limited print run and a glossy finish.
-
PSA 10 Value Increase a year ago: $1,300 → $3,600 (+172%)
-
PSA 9 Value Increase a year ago: $125 → $240
-
BGS 9.5 Value Increase a year ago: $337 → $1,200
-
Reason: Limited print run, glossy finish, and Bonds’ legendary stats.
#1. Michael Jordan
No surprise here, Michael Jordan dominates once again. Jordan is widely considered the greatest basketball player of all time with 6 NBA Championships, 5 MVP awards, 14-time all-star, and 10-time scoring champion. His 1998 Skybox EX Dunkin’ Go Nuts is one of the most desirable basketball inserts ever made.
-
PSA 10 Value Increase a year ago: $9,000 → $27,300 (+203%)
-
PSA 9 Value Increase a year ago: $4,400 → $10,500
-
BGS 10 Pristine a year ago: $9,500 → $27,600 (+191%)
-
Reason: Jordan’s enduring GOAT status and the rarity of high-grade inserts.
Why These Cards Are Winning Big
The explosive growth in these cards boils down to three factors:
-
Scarcity: High-grade versions (PSA 10, BGS 9.5/10) are limited and in demand.
-
Legacy: GOAT players like Jordan, Messi, and Bonds carry timeless value.
-
Market Confidence: Sports cards are now treated as a legitimate alternative asset class.
FAQs About the Sports Card Boom
1. Are sports cards still a good investment?
Yes, but focusing on iconic cards of GOAT players in high grades is key for long-term stability.
2. Which is better: PSA or BGS grading?
Both are respected. PSA often brings higher resale value, but BGS 10 “Pristine” can command premiums.
3. Will modern cards like Judge’s keep rising?
Yes, but player performance and longevity heavily influence value. GOATs like Jordan and Messi are safer bets.
4. What’s the best place to track card values?
Platforms like Market Movers provide real-time pricing data and market indexes for collectors.
5. Is now the right time to sell high-value cards?
If you own a card that’s tripled in a short time, it may be wise to lock in profits, though long-term GOAT cards usually appreciate steadily.
Conclusion
The past year has proven one thing: sports cards tied to the greatest athletes in history are more than just collectibles; they’re serious investments. From Jordan’s legendary Dunkin’ Go Nuts to Messi’s rookie sensation, the numbers speak for themselves.
Whether you’re a collector chasing nostalgia or an investor eyeing alternative assets, these cards represent the pinnacle of passion and profit in today’s booming sports card market.
-----------------------------------------------